🎸 My Personal Best 25 (Led Zeppelin Edition) – No.14: “Black Dog”

■For more on Led Zeppelin, see here・・・・➡ 🎈（Zeppelin）

🎸【Led Zeppelin Series】No.14 is…

No.14 is “Black Dog.”

Looking at this ranking, it wouldn’t be strange if some people still imagined it placed even higher.
“Black Dog” is a song that contains almost everything people associate with the name Led Zeppelin.
A powerful riff, a tightly strung performance, and the ability to change the air the moment the intro hits.
There are plenty of reasons it’s treated as a signature track.

Even so, this time I placed this song at No.14.
This is not the result of lowering my evaluation of it.
If anything, it’s the opposite: it’s the result of reflecting the song’s character directly in its position.

“Black Dog” is not a song that sinks deep.
It doesn’t give you much room to reminisce or to store up emotion.
Instead, from the instant it begins, it yanks the listener’s posture straight forward.
This “ability to make you lean in immediately” is quite unusual even within the Best 25.

After thinking about how that forward-leaning force should be used within the overall flow, No.14 felt natural to me.

Ultra-Short Summary

What’s depicted in this song is a situation where the narrator is strongly drawn to someone and keeps closing the distance.
The narrator throws out words as if checking the other person’s reaction and keeps moving forward without turning back, but how the relationship resolves is never shown.
At the center of the story is not an outcome, but a state in which the back-and-forth continues at the same temperature.
Rather than emotions changing drastically, the structure preserves a kind of motion that simply keeps going.

🎥 First, as always, please watch the official YouTube video.

🎬 Official Video Credit (Official Audio)
Title: Black Dog (Remaster)
Artist: Led Zeppelin
Album: Led Zeppelin IV
Release Year: 1971
Format: Official Audio (Remastered)
Provided by: Rhino Atlantic
Distributed by: Led Zeppelin Official YouTube Channel
🎵 Two-Line Commentary
A track where a ferocious riff and irregular vocal entrances collide, pulling the listener’s physical sense forward instantly.
Within “Led Zeppelin IV,” it doesn’t explain the flow—it switches the momentum itself on.

Japanese Credit (Official Live Footage)
Song: Black Dog
Artist: Led Zeppelin
Footage: Madison Square Garden show (July 1973 / New York)
Original Album: “Led Zeppelin IV”
Release Format: Official Live Video
Published by: Led Zeppelin Official YouTube Channel
Rights Notice: ℗ Atlantic Recording Corporation
🎼Two-Line Commentary
A 1973 live take where tense spacing and explosive propulsion intersect in front of a massive venue.
More than the studio version, the rhythmic game becomes visible, and the band’s instant concentration comes through vividly.

Basic Information on the Track

About the song covered here

• Artist: Led Zeppelin
• Title: Black Dog
• Album: Led Zeppelin IV
• Release Year: 1971

How it feels when it plays within the album

“Led Zeppelin IV,” when viewed as a whole, is a work whose center of gravity switches frequently.
There are quiet songs, songs that sink inward, and songs with a mythic scale.
As you listen, the depth of your breathing naturally changes.

Within that flow, when “Black Dog” hits, the air doesn’t widen—it tightens once.
Before you think, your body reacts.
Before understanding, the sense under your feet changes.
For me, this song doesn’t explain the album’s flow; it restarts the flow.

Facts Block

A structure where “the vocal stands in front”

If I had to name just one defining feature of “Black Dog,” I’d choose “a structure where the vocal stands in front.”
In this song, before the playing becomes the main character, the voice creates the space first.

The riff is intense, but it doesn’t dominate everything.
Once the vocal enters, the center of gravity doesn’t stay fixed—the role that steps forward switches from scene to scene.
That’s why, even when the sound becomes dense, it’s less likely to leave a sense of pressure behind.

This structure keeps the song from becoming heavy, but it also gives you no time to settle.
So the listener is pushed into the next turn without ever stopping.

An “Unstable Footing” Created by the Sound

Forward drive born from mismatched strides

When you listen to “Black Dog,” it can feel like you could fully give yourself to it—yet somehow you can’t quite surrender all the way.
Even when you think you’re riding the rhythm, your footing shifts by one step.
And still you don’t fall.
If anything, that instability becomes the momentum that carries you forward.

This song isn’t sound designed to reassure the listener.
It keeps you braced—“What’s coming next?”—and moves on without letting you rest.
That hardness makes the outline of the song stand out clearly.

Grasping the Story and Theme Through “Situation,” Not “Emotion”

Continuing to approach becomes the theme itself

What stays with me when reading the lyrics of “Black Dog” is that the narrator never arrives anywhere.
The will to get closer is clear.
The words keep being thrown.
And yet how the relationship turns out is never told to the end.

What’s depicted here is not success or failure, but a state of continuing to close the distance.
How the other person feels, whether they accepted it or rejected it—
those judgments are left on hold, while only the action keeps moving forward.

I take this structure less as a “love song” than as a record of a moment where momentum stops being controllable.
It’s not so much that emotion is swelling, but that no reason to stop can be found.
So the story doesn’t expand—it persists at the same temperature.

Hardness born from having no destination

In this song, from the instant the sound begins, the developments keep updating.
There is no signal to stop, and no space to look back.

What remains after it ends is not a neatly organized impression, but an air that feels as if the next thing might still come.
This sensation is what keeps “Black Dog” from being described as simple forward drive alone.

The Relationship Between Sound and Lyrics

The sound overtakes meaning

In “Black Dog,” the sound moves forward before you can try to understand the content of the lyrics.
Each time the vocal enters, the scene switches, but you’re given no extra space to explain that switch.

As a result, the listener is made to align less with organized meaning and more with movement.
I don’t think this relationship is accidental—it comes from the overall design of the track.

It’s not that the sound is ruled by the words—rather, the words are being driven forward by the sound.
That reversal gives this song its distinctive tension.

How My Own Timeline Has Changed

When I was younger, it was a symbol of “strength”

When I first listened to this song on repeat, I took “Black Dog” simply as a track with high intensity.

The moment it started, the air would change and the whole space would tighten at once.
I thought that speed of reaction was the song’s main appeal.

Back then, my attention didn’t reach the way the lyrics are built, or the structure in which the ending never quite settles.
I think I listened to it at that kind of distance—as one song to borrow momentum from.

Why No.14?

The most stable placement when you think in “time-type” terms

This song rises with the same intensity no matter when you listen.
Even as time passes, its sharpness doesn’t fade.
At the same time, it’s not the kind of song where the relationship deepens the more you live inside it.

Once it starts, it always pulls you forward.
But it doesn’t let you stay there for long.
“Black Dog” is a song that consistently stays on the side of immediacy.

If you think about that character along a time axis, it functions more honestly when inserted into the middle of the flow than when placed at an extreme beginning or endpoint.

Place it high, but don’t make it the core.
Don’t lower it so much that you lose the initial surge, either.

As the position where that balance feels most stable, No.14 fit perfectly for me.

---

Why This Order Matters

By inserting “Black Dog” at this point, the sense of distance and placement that has been building up to here is pulled back—once—to the body’s side of perception.

Move before you think.
Go forward before you organize.

Because that switch happens here, the songs that follow begin to sound not as “understanding,” but as “reaction.”

---

As a Summary

“Black Dog” is not a song that completes a story.
It isn’t a song that collects and resolves emotion, either.
It simply doesn’t stop the motion of stepping forward.

When you take that character not as “how highly it’s rated,” but as the role it plays within the flow, this song occupies an extremely important position within the Best 25.

A symbol of strength, yet not placed at the center.
A solid point of propulsion—something that pushes the flow onward.

For me, “Black Dog” is a track that rings most correctly precisely in this place.